You are here

Opinions

Email Updates - Click here to subscribe for automatic notices when this page is updated.

The District of Arizona offers a database of opinions for the years 2012 to current, listed by year and judge.

Judicial opinions from the District of Arizona, as well as other participating courts from throughout the nation, can also be accessed through the U.S. Government Publishing Office's United States Courts Opinions web page. To view judicial opinions on the GPO’s website, click here.

Datesort descending Description Judge
07/17/12 First National Acceptance Company V. Desert Springs Equestrian Center, L.L.C. (4:11-ap-00600-JMM) 07/17/12

Memorandum Decision

Judge James M. Marlar (recalled)
07/17/12 Mountainside Fitness Centers Of Gilbert, L.L.C. And Thomas John Hatten (2:10-bk-23734-CGC) 07/17/12

Order Approving Stipulated Briefing Schedule Pursuant to Under Advisement Decision

Judge Charles G. Case II (retired)
07/17/12 First National Acceptance Co. v. Desert Springs Equestrian Center, L.L.C. (4:11-ap-00600-JMM) 07/17/12

Holding: It appears that all of the fees generated by FNAC were reasonable, and taken only in efforts to move FNAC's claims forward to obtain payment or to foreclose upon its collateral in the face of a defaulted promissory note. Moreover, all other fees incurred were due to defending against the positions taken by Desert Springs--through two bankruptcies and its (never-pressed) "defenses" to FNAC's adversary proceeding. Desert Springs' arguments against awarding FNAC's fees and costs are not persuasive. Counsel for Desert Springs will be ordered to pay such fees and costs from the sums held in the trust account for said purpose.  

Judge James M. Marlar (recalled)
07/23/12 Esquilin V. Gmac Mortgage, Inc Et Al (2:12-ap-00731-CGC) 07/23/12

Memorandum Decision Re: Dismissal of Adversary Proceeding

Judge Charles G. Case II (retired)
08/07/12 Luke Cusack (4:11-bk-32452-JMM) 08/07/12

Memorandum Decsion

Judge James M. Marlar (recalled)
08/07/12 Gabriel Edwardo Torres And Maria Rosario Torres (2:10-bk-41559-EWH) 08/07/12

Stipulated Order Confirming Plan and Fee Application

Judge Eileen W. Hollowell (retired)
08/16/12 Hanson V. Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. (2:12-ap-01221-RTB) 08/16/12

Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law re: Complaint to Determine Secured Status and Avoid Lien

Judge Redfield T. Baum (recalled)
08/28/12 Bataa/Kierland, Llc (2:11-bk-05850-RJH) 08/28/12

Opinion Denying Designation of Vote

Judge Randolph J. Haines (retired)
09/04/12 Bataa/Kierland, LLC (2:11-bk-05850-RJH) 09/04/12

Holding: A secured creditor has moved to “designate,” or disqualify, another secured creditor’s acceptance of the plan of reorganization, pursuant to Bankruptcy Code § 1126(e),1 alleging that the acceptance was not in good faith. The Court denies the motion as untimely and moot and because there is no evidence the vote was cast out of malice, for any improper purpose, or for any reason other than enlightened self-interest consistent with both the voter’s and the plan proponent’s capacities in the bankruptcy case. 

Judge Randolph J. Haines (retired)
09/04/12 Bataa/Kierland, Llc (2:11-bk-05850-RJH) 09/04/12

Amended Opinion Denying Designation of Vote

Judge Randolph J. Haines (retired)

Pages