You are here

Opinions

Email Updates - Click here to subscribe for automatic notices when this page is updated.

The District of Arizona offers a database of opinions for the years 2012 to current, listed by year and judge.

Judicial opinions from the District of Arizona, as well as other participating courts from throughout the nation, can also be accessed through the U.S. Government Publishing Office's United States Courts Opinions web page. To view judicial opinions on the GPO’s website, click here.

Date Description Judgesort descending
02/02/06 Stanley V. Mackenzie Et Al (2:04-ap-00817-CGC) 02/02/06

Under Advisement Decision re: Trial

Judge Charles G. Case II (retired)
12/04/07 Holiday Road Holdings Ii Llc (2:07-bk-06223-CGC) 12/04/07

Memorandum Decision re: Motion to Dismiss, in the Alternative, Motion for Relief from the Automatic Stay

Judge Charles G. Case II (retired)
09/28/06 Hd Partners, Llc V. Eq Acquisitions 2003, Inc. (2:05-ap-00287-CGC) 09/28/06

Under Advisement Decision re: SWTV Production Services, Inc.'s Motion for Summary Judgment and EQ's Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment

Judge Charles G. Case II (retired)
07/23/08 Stockman V. Pheaa/Aes Et Al (2:05-ap-00799-CGC) 07/23/08

Under Advisement Decision re: Motion to Submit Additional Evidence for Consideration on Remand

Judge Charles G. Case II (retired)
11/05/12 Alzubidi Et Al V. Abulaban (2:11-ap-01795-CGC) 11/05/12

Under Advisement Decision Re: Plaintiffs' Complaint Objecting to Defendant's Discharge

Judge Charles G. Case II (retired)
03/25/10 Fortier V. Adr Contracting, Inc. (2:08-ap-00620-CGC) 03/25/10

Amended Under Advisement Decision

Judge Charles G. Case II (retired)
06/14/07 Gail E Gross (2:04-bk-21324-CGC) 06/14/07

Under Advisement Decision re: Trustee's Motion to Sell

Judge Charles G. Case II (retired)
05/02/05 Warfield V. Thompson (2:04-ap-01166-SSCP) 05/02/05

Memorandum Decision

Judge Charles G. Case II (retired)
06/19/06 Mitchell Et Al V. College Properties Limited Partnership Et Al (2:06-ap-00063-CGC) 06/19/06

Under Advisement Decision

Judge Charles G. Case II (retired)
09/21/12 Red Mountain Machinery Company v. Comerica Bank (2:09-ap-00941-CGC) 09/21/12

Holding: Dierich’s activities fall short of what they should have been and the Court has found that some of those activities breached his fiduciary duty to RMMC. Indeed, in the many ways, the facts are so egregious that ever recurring questions are -- can’t something be done about this? Isn’t there some remedy for what he did? How can it be right for him to "get a pass?" But the law requires more than bad acts. It insists that those bad acts be the cause of concrete damage to the plaintiff. And, in this case, the proof is just not there on this critical point, except to the extent Dierich was paid during 2009 by RMMC while at the same time acting in his own interests. For these reasons, judgment will be given to the Defendants on all claims other than for salary disgorgement during 2009. 

Judge Charles G. Case II (retired)

Pages